Discussion about this post

User's avatar
HamburgerToday's avatar

This is a good essay.

White racial confidence for the majority of Whites is going to come from positive interactions with the White Vanguard.

The White Vanguard ought to already have all the 'self-belief' necessary to act in the world as a positive change agent.

But for there to be a *movement*, a large number of 'concerned' - but not yet committed - Whites need to trust 'the movement'.

Why should they trust a movement that cannot decide on fundamental questions regarding the use of power?

The internecine squabbling over NSDAPery within White Nationalism is an indication that what we have right now is not a 'movement' in any conceivable way, but, rather a *conversation*.

This isn't a bad thing. Or a good thing. It's simply where things stand right now.

The White Vanguard - people like you and I who have decided that the survival and thriving of the White race is the priority - need to understand our current situation with clarity, not regret or frustration. Instead, we should act in a manner that takes advantage of the situation.

The NSDAPers want everyone in the pro-White movement to accept their leadeship.

That's being resisted.

Rather than lament the fact that we cannot 'get our act together', it might be more productive to recognize that 'the act' we're actually a part of *is* 'together'. We're in the conversation/consciousness-raising part of the process of collective White self-actualization, not the 'organization' phase of that process.

I say, take pleasure (and even hope) in the fact that we're *having* a conversation that many voices can take part in. These moments of 'squabbling' and dissension are part of the healing process. Nothing could be more disastrous than premature 'organization' before our race is ready to commit to White collective assertion.

As I've said many times, in my view the essence of 'White Nationalism' - of pro-White advocacy - is 'Whites caring about Whites because they are White *and no other reason*'.

The NSDAPers still care more about whether you're a NSDAP-enjoyer than whether you're White and need care and concern.

Expand full comment
Aodhan MacMhaolain's avatar

The problem is that the Nazis have been the ones pressing the ticket. They spurned the creation of the alt right and led the meme war. They spurned the creation of active clubs more than any other group. From their camp rose folkism, which has spread out from NS and German stuff to other groups.

I really don't think you guys even fully understand what Joel is saying. It's not like he wants to resurrect and give every White nation German National Socialism. It seems that his idea is that each group takes the core values of NS for themselves. This view is at least expressed by Thomas Sewell.

Expand full comment
12 more comments...

No posts